News Home

Another Student Attacker Inadequately Punished After Crime

Another Student Attacker Inadequately Punished at La Plata HS

La Plata, Charles County - 11/1/2007

Printer friendly

By Staff Writer Heather Bartlett

Click on document to enlarge.
Click on document to enlarge.

Lisa Royer* only wanted to ensure the safety of her son.  Last May, after two boys attending La Plata High School with her son beat him severely enough to send the boy to Civista Hospital for treatment, she phoned La Plata High School principal, Garth Bowling and his staff repeatedly to find out when or if the boys would return to school.  She was concerned for her son’s safety if his attackers were still around.  La Plata school officials told her nothing. 

It was only after attending the court proceedings that resulted from the attack that she gained any insight into what was happening with the attackers.  Still, she was very concerned that her son’s attackers could return to school any day, and she would have no idea when her son was vulnerable to another attack.

“It was bad enough that they weren’t protecting my son, but now they were making it so I can’t protect him.  When did our administrators stop caring about the kids?” Royer exclaimed.

After reading The Bay Net’s account of the recent incident (Stabbed at School by Classmate) where a La Plata High School girl stabbed a classmate with a tapestry needle, Royer thought her son’s experience also needed to come to light.

.

Attacked and Beaten

According to witness accounts, at the end of the school day on May 22, 2007, Royer’s 14-year-old son was heading to the school bus when two other male students attacked him from behind.  The accused are a 16-year-old, whose name we will not release because he is a juvenile, and his 18-year-old brother, whose name below is a matter of public record.

Remains of the boot print on the
victim's chest. 
The attack evidently stemmed from an earlier incident during a class.  The 16-year-old made a joke that poked fun at young Royer, but he laughed along anyway.  Royer said her son’s laughter irritated his tormentor, who then began threatening young Royer in earnest.  According to the school’s official statement, the 16-year-old became so abusive that he was removed from class.  He was, however, allowed to stay in the office until dismissal.

Ms. Royer wasn’t aware of the classroom incident until the school nurse phoned to tell her that she needed to come pick up her son.  The nurse told her he’d been attacked and that he needed to be taken to the hospital.

“When I got there I couldn’t believe it.  He was unrecognizable,” Royer told The Bay Net.  “His face was all swollen.  He had a boot print on his chest.  They should have called an ambulance, I think.”

The police report prepared by Officer Kaylor described the injuries young Royer suffered, “Two large contusions under both eyes, a cut under his left eye, and a red bruise on his left side.  He was taken to Civista Medical Center for treatment.  As of this report there is too much swelling to determine any breaks.”

.

Continuing in Company with Danger

Royer told The Bay Net that only a couple of days after the incident her son was forced to take important assessment tests in the same room with one of the boys who assaulted him.   Her concern that she wouldn’t know when her son was vulnerable to additional attack was validated, the assailant had returned to school.

“My son also said there was another student attacked that same day and [that student’s] attacker was there [taking the test] as well.  Maybe if students didn’t have to be in fear when taking a test, because they are worried about their safety, they may have a better chance to pass their tests.  I don’t understand why those students were allowed to take a state mandated test if they were suspended, better yet, why the attackers weren’t sent to a different testing site.”

Royer said the testing situation led her to believe that the school only seemed to be concerned with the testing.  For her, the entire situation continued to escalate because of Principal Bowling and his La Plata High School administration seemed to demonstrate a complete lack of empathy and concern for her son’s safety. 

She told The Bay Net that although she tried several times to contact Principal Bowling, she couldn’t even get him to acknowledge her.

“We eventually caught him in the upstairs office; and when we asked to speak to him, he said, ‘I guess if I have to’,”  Royer stated.

“I questioned why my son was taking a test [with his attacker] and [Principal Bowling] said they were aware of it and his administration had it under control.  Yet, when I approached one of the administrators they claimed they had no idea,” Royer stated.

.

Staff Mistakes & Mis-deeds

To Royer’s further frustration, she discovered that Vice Principal Pauline Johnson had talked to one witness after the girl gave her statement; and, according to the girl, Johnson tried to confuse her and made her rewrite the statement.  This is a copy of the girl’s statement regarding that incident with Johnson.

The official school report of the incident, as provided to Royer differs from eye-witnesses’ statements.  In the report, the school described the 16-year-old’s attack on Royer’s son, and then adds that Jamil Thomas (name used with parental permission) intervened on young Royer’s behalf.  The account continues, saying that a second fight then broke out between the 16-year-old, Thomas, and the Royer boy, in which the 18-year-old also got involved. 

However, statements from witnesses describe the two brothers attacking the Royer boy jointly; and, when no official came to aid the victim, Thomas (who saw the whole incident from his seat on the bus) disembarked and intervened. 

Thomas’ mother gave The Bay Net this account of the aftermath.

“Originally when this fight happened, Mrs. Johnson was trying to make light of it. She was saying that the fight only took place for about 25 seconds before adults broke it up. She also kept threatening that Jamil (my son) could be suspended because he was involve in the fight also.

“… I said to go ahead and suspend my son, because it is pretty sad that a 15-year-old has to run off of a bus to help a 14-year-old that is being beat by a 16 and 18-year-old.”

Ultimately, Thomas was not suspended.

Potentially, the most disturbing part of La Plata High School’s official account is that it seems to state that Principal Bowling and his staff used only the offending 16-year-old’s account of the incident. (see graphic above article) 

Ms Thomas said she asked Mrs. Johnson for accounts of the incident from students who were on the bus right next to the incident.   When Ms Thomas checked back after a couple of days she was told that Johnson still had not questioned anybody on that bus. 

Ms Royer and Ms Thomas’ concerns for their sons’ safety are validated by Vice Principle Lynn Arnold’s official statement.  Arnold quotes the threats that the 16-year-old continued to yell at Thomas even as the attacker was restrained by a police officer and hauled to the school’s office after the fight.

“I am going to kill you!  I will f*** you up!  I’ll find out where you live!  You are dead!”

To give their children some sort of protection, Royer and Thomas filed Peace Orders against the brothers in court.

Thomas told The Bay Net that from the court proceedings she understood that the 16-year-old had previously attended Thomas Stone but transferred to La Plata after a previous assault incident from 2005, possibly at the school.  The Bay Net has been unable to confirm that information through official channels because school authorities cannot release this information.

Royer told The Bay Net that the 18-year-old adult, Gregory Johnson, has had his court case continued until December. 

According to information Royer heard during court proceedings, both brothers are now students at Lackey High School.

.


*Name changed to protect the victim.

.

Heather Bartlett is TheBayNet.com’s Waldorf and Arts Correspondent.  In her other life, she’s an artist , co-creator of the political group blog Charles County Café.  To contact her about this article, Waldorf issues or Arts events comment below or email bartlett@thebaynet.com.

Site Meter


News Feedback NOTE: Views expressed below do not reflect the views or opinions of The Bay Net, Bay Media Services, Inc. or the employees of Bay Media Services, Inc.


This feature is only available to registered members.
Register for free today to take full advantage of The Bay Net's features!


To Register: Click Here

Already a Registered Member? Log In Below:




 


Send This Story to a Friend!






Back to Top




© 2005-2010 Bay Media Services & The Bay Net